Director: Derek Cianfrance
Year: 2010
Country: USA
Studio: The Weinstein Company
Rating: **** (4/5)
A project nearly a dozen years in the making, Derek Cianfrance's sophomore directorial effort Blue Valentine is obviously an intense labor of love. Brilliantly cast, fantastically edited, and marvelously directed, it's a near-flawless depiction of emotional turmoil. Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams are both perfect for their roles, and their dedication to every aspect of their characters is evident throughout this two-hour obstacle course of life, love, and all the things that manage to screw it up in unimaginable and unforgiving ways.
The film is told through a series of fragmented events with a timeline that jumps back and forth between the past and the present, which gives the viewer the ability to view the contrasts between how the couple feels about each other at both the end of their relationship and the beginning. While it's not exactly a new or inventive technique, the way Cianfrance edits the film gives it a very emotionally affecting appeal, and he does a much better job of doing it than others have done in the past. The camera-work is a little shaky at times and at others very steady, but the changing of the filming technique goes hand in hand with the changing of the story. It almost has a documentary-type feel during certain scenes, which makes viewing the on-screen issues of the characters seem even more lifelike and realistic.
The plot isn't overly convoluted, but it isn't overly simplistic either. While viewers will go into watching the film knowing the outcome of the characters, that sort of thing doesn't matter. It's the journey these people go through and watching it unfold that's the most interesting, and most important, part of the experience. It centers on Dean (Ryan Gosling), a man who makes up for what he lacks in intelligence and ambition with his romantic notions and dedication to what he feels to be most important in life -- providing for his wife and family. His wife, Cindy (Michelle Williams) is a woman who obviously struggles with the decisions she's made in her life and constantly questions whether or not she made the right ones. She obviously wants to be in love and be loved, but her inner demons stemming from a tumultuous family upbringing keep getting in the way and she never truly allows herself the chance to be happy. Bring a child into the mix (Frankie, played by an adorable Faith Wladyka), and you have a situation that's bound to explode.
Getting too much into the plot would take away from the pleasure of seeing the events fold out on screen. It's so well-done and thought-provoking that it's something that needs to be seen by everyone to fully understand and appreciate. Much like the film Closer, it's not a movie that you should take a date to see. Its bleak view of love and depictions of its futility are bound to cause a bunch of unnecessary arguments and over-assessments. But really, the fact that this is one of the view films to really take such an un-Hollywood approach to romance makes it all that much more worthy of your time. The characters on screen could be any American family struggling through any relationship, and viewers can learn a lot by watching them. Overall, this is a terrific film, and one of the few "Oscar Buzz" films of the year that actually delivers on all fronts. Highly recommended.